Sugar, Butter, Flour: The Waitress Pie Cookbook by Jenna Hunterson

Inspired by the hit Broadway musical Waitress, Sugar, Butter, Flour: The Waitress Pie Cookbook brings Jenna Hunterson’s world of baking to life. Known for turning emotions into pies, Jenna’s recipes capture both the sweetness and the bittersweet moments of the story.

This cookbook isn’t just about pies—it’s about comfort, creativity, and finding joy in the kitchen, just like Jenna does in the musical.

🥧 What’s Inside the Cookbook?

The book includes over 75 recipes, ranging from classics to imaginative new creations:

• 🍋 Betrayed by My Eggs Pie – tangy and unforgettable
• 🍏 Falling in Love Apple Pie – warm and comforting
• 🍫 Chocolate Cream Dream Pie – rich and indulgent
• 🥜 Nuts About You Pie – playful and crunchy
• 🍓 Strawberry-Ooh-La-La Pie – sweet with a touch of sass

Every recipe reflects Jenna’s unique ability to turn life’s ups and downs into delicious desserts.

🌟 Why Fans Love It

• Directly inspired by the Waitress musical and its songs
• Perfect for fans of baking, theater, and heartfelt storytelling
• Includes both classic pies and inventive flavor combinations
• A collectible piece for Broadway lovers and cookbook collectors
• Recipes that balance nostalgia, humor, and comfort

This is more than a pie cookbook—it’s a slice of Broadway magic you can bake at home.

💬 Join the Conversation

Which Waitress pie would you bake first — Chocolate Cream Dream or Falling in Love Apple Pie?
Tell us in the comments and share your own pie creations!